In a symbolic nod to social conservatives, House Republicans will introduce a bill that defines a 20-week-old fetus as a "pain-capable unborn child." Never mind that many in the scientific community do not agree with their assessment, or that the bill has no chance of passage in the Senate, these members of the GOP are sticking to the culture war script.
Their proposed law would require abortion providers to inform mothers that evidence exists that the procedure would cause pain to the child, and offer the mothers anesthesia for the baby. As CBS reports, however, the University of California recently looked at all the credible studies conducted on the question, and concluded that fetal pain would not occur until the seventh month of pregnancy, or the 28th week.
If we, as a society, deem the scientific evidence of fetal pain as the threshold for when to outlaw abortion, then perhaps we will reach that long-sought-after middle ground. But don't count on it. The pro-life movement has made it clear that their ultimate goal is a Nicaraguan-style total banning of the procedure.
Perhaps no one has written more thoughtfully (or controversially) on the topic of abortion than Princeton ethics professor Peter Singer. To try and sum up his sophisticated argument in a blog is not really possible, but he reflects on the pain question, as well as what it is to be human, and illustrates the fallacies put forth by both "pro-life" and "pro-choice" advocates. For further reading, try Practical Ethics.
Hot Topics
2008 Contenders
Hot Issues
Resources
House GOP Parting Shot: Abortion
Most Recent Comments
Politics Video
HST protest
Smitherman to run for Toronto mayor
Smitherman to run for Toronto mayorRebagliati will run
Snowboarder slides into politics
Miller won't seek 3rd term as Toronto mayor
President 2008 |
Democrats |
Republicans |
President Bush |
Iraq War |
News Bloggers |

Reader Comments ( Page 1 of 1)
1. mvic915@aol.com
This Church is evidently in California, it is no wonder that a "Christian" pastor has made the invite to `Bama'
Victor Mirota at 10:10AM on Nov 30th 2006
2. IF conservatives evangelicals spent as much time following the Bible as they do trying to dictate social policy we wouldn't have to worry about social policy. Two big commandments, "love your neighbor as yourself" and "go and make disciples of all the world." If they would follow all the teachings of teh scriptures, they could rock the world.
robin at 10:43AM on Nov 30th 2006
3. I was raised to believe that if it is not my business,don't make it my business. I am not a woman, have never been and dont plan to be one in the near future. Therefore who am I to tell a woman what she can and cannot do with her own body.
This said, I find it strange that all the faces on the evening news spouting anti-abotion retoric are all white middle aged men who were never taught to mind thier own business. Although I suppose it is possible that one or two of them were once 16 year old girls in trouble.
sean hutchison at 6:46PM on Dec 8th 2006