Rudy Giuliani took the MoveOn.org ad calling General David Petraeus, David "Betray Us," and made it a campaign plus for him. He's gone after them hard and rightfully so. General Petraeus made our esteemed elected leaders look even more buffoonish than usual. He was calm, answered their questions with authority and acted as one would expect a high-ranking military man to act, with class and dignity. MoveOn attacked a good man for partisan political purposes and Rudy is now using it as a weapon:
As for the candidates on the Dems side, Richard Cohen takes them to task today:
Almost instantly, though, it got pretty hard to find a Democratic presidential candidate willing to dispute MoveOn.org. To his credit, Joe Biden did. "I don't buy into that," he said. "This is an honorable guy. He's telling the truth." But lonesome Joe, whose virtues have yet to come to the attention of the vast and apathetic electorate, was seconded only by Joe Lieberman, not a presidential candidate, and John Kerry, a man whose tomorrow is yesterday. When Clinton was asked about the ad, she avoided answering.
It may seem unfair to single out Clinton in this matter when the bunker in which she took shelter was crowded with her fellow quivering candidates. But Clinton is the front-runner, quite possibly the next president of the United States, so it is reasonable to focus on her and wonder if, as some allege, she does indeed have a spine. In this instance, it was nowhere to be found.
This was the opportunity for Hillary Clinton so show that she has what it takes to be commander-in -chief (shudder) of the U.S. military and she punted. A more astute politician -- such as her husband -- would have seen the advantage of defending a career Army officer and highly regarded leader and bent over backwards to make it known that they didn't agree with the offensive ad. Clinton failed and Rudy grabbed the ball and ran with it. That action may have cemented his cred with conservatives who abhor the MoveOn crowd and conservative Democrats who feel Hillary has wandered a little too far into left field for their tastes (note: link to NY Times piece for TimeSelect members until midnight tonight).
MoveOn has accomplished two things with this inane ad campaign, a campaign they will continue to run: they've alienated a good portion of the electorate and pushed them toward Rudy who could hold them with his unique blend of social liberalism and national defense conservatism.


Reader Comments ( Page 1 of 1)
1. Clinton never dissed Petraeus is any way, so why would she need to apologize? And why didn't she attack the ad, probably because a recent poll shows over 60% of Americans believe Petraeus is just saying whatever the president wants.
for political commentary, visit:
http://www.politidose.com/
Patrick at 8:36PM on Sep 18th 2007
2. Every individual citizens serving this country whether in the military or anywhere else deserve to be congratulated and our full support.
Kava at 12:39PM on Sep 19th 2007
3. " probably because a recent poll shows over 60% of Americans believe Petraeus is just saying whatever the president wants."
Yeah go with the poll!
At least HST ( a democrat with Character) did not bother with the polls, otherwise Tommy D would have become president
johnzabchuk at 4:25PM on Sep 19th 2007
4. Is every one of these 'Stump' bloggers a conservative? It seems the media so atacked the deck with conservatives that they are stuck with a full stable of smart ass neocons who have now become embarassingly irrelevant. Check out this article by Dick Cavett (NY TImes Select is dead, it's all free now!)http://cavett.blogs.nytimes.com/2007/04/26/when-the-press-broke-down/ , this is the best piece on the shameful American media I've seen.
tom at 11:12PM on Sep 19th 2007
5. "Every individual citizens serving this country whether in the military or anywhere else deserve to be congratulated and our full support."
They have our full support, however that does not mean that we cannot say that they are doing something wrong and that they had better change course or they will be looking for a new job!
Giving someone 'support' does not mean that you gloss over everything that you disagree with them about. In fact, the best support you could give someone is to explain to them why you don't like what they are doing, in hopes that they will change their pathway in life.
Christopher Kidwell at 12:06AM on Sep 20th 2007
6. #5 Chrtopher Kidwell at 12:06AM
Didn't they (Congress) did that already with the surge.General Petraus came back and report to Congress on the success of the surge.But at the same time we as civilize people have an attitude of congratulating him for putting his life on the line in obeying the authorities that sent him there while living his wife and children behind.And the same goes to each and every individual service men and women of the military.
Kava at 10:47PM on Sep 22nd 2007