"Who do you think you are? Pavarotti?"
We all know who they are: they're the ones your friends, relatives and teachers teased you with, sometimes affectionately - sometimes not so...
When you wouldn't stop cracking wise in class: "All right, all right. That's enough out of you, Bob Hope."
When you first started getting the hang of the trumpet: "Well, listen to you, Louis Armstrong."
When you trip walking on to the dance floor: "Way to go, Baryshnikov."
When that piece of art you made really kind of kicks ass: "You're a regular Da Vinci."
What that poem actually sounds pretty good: "Say, you're another Shakespeare!"
When your performance in that play brought down the house: "Now how about that! You sure I shouldn't call you Laurence Olivier?"
And when you sing your lungs out in the shower - as we all still do - there's only one response: "Hey, hey, keep it down in there. Who do you think you are? Pavarotti?"
Luciano Pavarotti equaled opera in the public consciousness. Most of us - myself included - don't fully understand what we lost. But we know we lost something more than a tremendous voice.
That's why the treatment of Pavarotti's death by the television media made me sad. I'd made sure to tune into NBC's Today the morning after his death to watch the entirety of their first twenty minutes. This is the "hard news" section. The placement of, and time alloted to, each story reflects what NBC News thinks is important.
I'd hoped that they'd lead off with Pavarotti's death. Fifteen years ago they would have. Alas the first twenty minutes of NBC's Today was dominated by Fred Thompson (of NBC's Law and Order) announcing his candidacy on NBC's Tonight Show the night before. Hardly big news, since the announcement had been announced the week before. (NBC is relentless: this season expect Fred Thompson to show up as a character on Days of Our Lives, a judge on Bravo's Project Runway, and a model on Deal or No Deal.) Pavarotti's death was given the last two minutes or so. Not a retrospective. No interviews. Just a glorified bumper.
I held out hope that that night my pal Larry King would give it up for Pavarotti. Larry's audience is older, more likely to appreciate Pavarotti's place in the culture. Plus he'd interviewed Pavarotti. Perhaps he'd rerun the interview? But no. The hour was jam packed with updates on missing blond women. Larry ran a very short clip at the end of the hour.
This sounds like a very precious complaint, as if I'm swooning with indignation, my manservant daubing my brow, as I collapse onto my fainting couch. "Oh, Sebastian, what barbarism!"
But it does depress me that Paris' jail travails get top billing, when the death of a man who deepened and expanded us is an afterthought.
Of course the real victims are classical music journalists. They are an endangered species. Newspapers, where most of these reporters have worked, have been laying them off, replacing them (when reporters are replaced at all) with media writers.
This is why I've decided that I must help save The New York Times' Anthony Tommasini, the newspaper's chief classical music critic. He already lost a big subject with the July death of Beverly Sills, about whom he wrote beautifully. I've never met Tommasini but I'm convinced that his job is at stake with the death of Pavarotti. If a few more pillars in the classical music world croak, he's toast; he'll be replaced with someone who covers Chat Rooms or reviews YouTube clips.
To survive, It is imperative that Tommasini preserve the remaining Two Tenors, whatever the cost. They are his lifeblood right now. He should rush to the side of Placido Domingo. (Domingo is a bigger fish than Jose Carreras.) Begin monitoring his diet: a low-fat, low-cholesterol diet is a start. (I can't find the stat on Domingo's blood pressure, so I'll defer on sodium intake.) Make sure he sleeps and exercises - though remember, cardio is less important than anaerobic exercise at age 66. Happiness is important, too. Make sure he gets lots of sex. But not so much sex that it puts a strain on his heart. St. John's Wort and Airborne are also handy. As he gets older, a common cold gets dangerous.
If, in say 20 years, Carreras kicks it while you're offering life-support to Domingo, don't panic: The Weekend at Bernie's strategy works here. Just prop up Carreras. Domingo is loud enough for the both of them.
This is just a start. If anyone else has suggestions for how Anthony Tommasini can keep the Two Tenors alive, please weigh in. No scheme is too wacky. The survival of classical music journalism - and our appreciation of figures like Pavarotti - depends on it!
***
Below is a very special comment that came in concerning the post above. It's from Liz:
Mo Rocca, mille grazie! for dedicating your blog space today to a tribute to the phenomenon we call Luciano Pavarotti and indeed to the survival of opera itself in the US.
We know what an amazing voice he had; his legacy is vast. He was too modest to ever acknowledge that his singing was anything more than a gift of god, but he worked at singing despite what some of his critics seemed to think.
His biggest concern always was that "she", his voice, would not show up for a performance. He was always conscious of not disappointing his audiences.
I was privileged to work closely with the Maestro at the Opera Company of Philadelphia when he held his four vocal competitions over a ten-year period in the 80s and 90s. I did public relations and English/Italian translations for his competitions. He often teased me mercilessly to lure me out of professional mode. Didn't work. When we were in interviews he sometimes get bored answering the same question over and over. He was so damned mischievous sometimes that he would pretend he didn't understand a question asked in English and then turn to me and in Italian tell me to make something up to tell the interviewer. He would always grin from ear to ear watching me squirm. The first few times I refused and shot the question back to him. But I got him good once and he never did it again: I told the Reuters interviewer that Pavarotti had invited him to up to his (luxurious) hotel suite to continue the interview over aperatives. He couldn't back down, so Pavarotti hosted us for another hour of interview! Exactly what he hated doing. He told the story of my outrageous defiance to everyone who would listen.
Yet I have the most amazingly vivid memories of how hard he worked with the young singers. Pavarotti was tireless on their behalf: rehearsals, voice exercises, repetition of vocal lines, posture, inflection, stage presence. Master classes really. But always the quest for excellence. He loved talent and loved to nurture it. The prize for all of his winners was singing onstage with him, in fact, he took about 20 of the winners to China to sing La Boheme for Chinese audiences. While there, he sang with a master of the Chinese opera in Beijing, dressing elaborately in gorgeous layers of silk robes and sashes, wildly colorful make up, enormous headdress, and banging on a huge gong while he imitated the pinched nasal tones of his Chinese counterpart in an effort to sing complimentarily. Breathtaking!
Pavarotti was unselfish and generous to his fans as well. The things I got him to sign, write notes on! The bazillion fans I arranged him to be photographed with! It was all, he would always say, to promote the love of opera. He was awed by the fact that when he appeared for the first time on the Tonight Show with Johnny Carson, more people saw him perform in just that night than saw the great tenor Enrico Caruso in his entire lifetime.
He was all about promoting opera, from the Three Tenors Concerts for mass audiences to the Pavarotti and Friends concerts with European stars to benefit children caught in wars and famine worldwide.
Funny, Mo, that you mention singing in the shower: at least once a day someone would say to him, "I can't sing very well, but I sound great in the shower." He would invariably say, "I sound best in the shower myself." If it was a woman he would always add, "Want to join me in a duet?" Corny as hell, but he actually loved hearing his voice in the shower and, of course, would take any opportunity to flirt shamelessly with a beautiful woman.
I could go on and on....there are so many wonderful stories that provide glimpses into the legend. It was so much fun, so much work, so much talent...did I mention so much work? But I loved my time with Luciano. (He insisted that he be called by his first name by his colleagues, but I wound up calling him Maestro most of the time.) I have been mentioned very generously in one of his memoirs in a chapter called "My Greatest Night in Opera". A wild ride of a dramatic story! Memories for a lifetime. And, yes, I kept a journal.
My heart broke when I heard last year of Pavarotti's illness; I wrote him twice to wish him well during his treatments and received typed replies personalized and signed by my erstwhile friend and colleague. Today is terrifically sad, but I was fortunate to spend the evening with friends and former colleagues here in Philadelphia singing, toasting and reminiscing. The stories were hilarious. Pavarotti was very playful and just a big kid. He would have loved our little party.
Since I knew his first wife Adua and his older two daughters a bit, I was invited by Pavarotti's family to his funeral today in Modena via a rather complicated email setup. I got my code to download my personal invitation just for the sake of it, but had to decline since getting there was impossible on such short notice. I think being there would have been a terribly emotional event for those who knew him.
If asked, I'd say his greatest legacy would be his voice, first, and his teaching, second, b/c the singers he tutored carry his technique and his unerring sense of the music into the future.
And I think the greatest tribute in the world to The Great One would be to listen and share opera with other music lovers in order to keep the love of opera alive.
Add your comments
Please keep your comments relevant to this blog entry. Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments.
When you enter your name and email address, you'll be sent a link to confirm your comment, and a password. To leave another comment, just use that password.
To create a live link, simply type the URL (including http://) or email address and we will make it a live link for you. You can put up to 3 URLs in your comments. Line breaks and paragraphs are automatically converted — no need to use <p> or <br> tags.
Mo's Video
The Sound of a Smoke-Free Barack...Almost two years ago we speculated on how Barack Obama's voice would change if he stopped smoking. ...
Most Popular Stories
- Don't Like Goodbyes...
- Pittsburgh Steelers: Is it Time to get some Cheerleaders?
- How NOT to give an Oscar Acceptance Speech
- Could Jim Belushi Win the Nobel Peace Prize?
- Spring Break Sexy T-Shirt Removal Training!
- Quest for the Crown 5: Plastic Wrap to Make you Less Fat!
- Quest for the Crown 4: Work Those Heels!
Most Commented On
-
Coming Soon
Recent Comments
- Roert Dean on General Clark is Absolutely Right!
- Steve J. on Introducing Power Line AOL
- Saint Brian the Godless on Obama and the Reagan Doctrine
- Saint Brian the Godless on Obama and the Reagan Doctrine
- mac on Obama and the Reagan Doctrine
- Saint Brian the Godless on Obama and the Reagan Doctrine
- Richelle on Obama and the Reagan Doctrine
Mo's Bio
Top News Headlines
Political Machine Blog
- Salahis May Get Congressional Subpoenas, Top Democrat Warns
- The Yadda Yadda Monologues
- Sandra Tsing Loh: Stealing Wireless and Making Us Feel Good
- Transportation Committee Head Says Infrastructure Spending Equals Jobs
- Desiree Rogers Will Skip Hearing; New White House Social Guidelines
- Lynn Sweet on Hardball: Key Support for Obama's Afghanistan Timetable
- Obama's Timeline No Guarantee of Afghanistan Withdrawal, Senators Told


Reader Comments ( Page 1 of 2)
1. I too am saddened that Pavarotti has not received the coverage he deserves. I know, that there are many things happening in today's fast paced and crime ridden world. Although, I would've hoped that we could've taken some time to reflect upon someone who made opera mainstream. Dare I say that Luciano Pavarotti was one of, if not only opera singer that many people could name? For now, I think we'll have to wait until after the MTV VMA's in order to watch a quickly composed tribute to the opera genius. As long as he gets his due, he may just have to be okay with it arriving a little late.
Miss B. at 7:59AM on Sep 8th 2007
2. mo, 2 words for you...andre bocelli. he is wonderful. beautiful voice. right now a bit underappreciated. have seen several of his specials on pbs and he deserves to be up there as a modern great. i agree that we must appreciate and preserve the remaining icons of opera...but if mr. tommasini wants to survive, he will need to move forward to what is happening now. opera has moved forward. i like to think of them as 'crossover' kinda singers. all the strength and beauty of the classic opera notes, but in a more modern type of song. another great example would be josh groban. while yes, he has some pop style songs, if you listen to his cd's and not just what you hear on the radio, then you would see he does italian also. i recently saw him in concert here in charlotte and he has an amazing voice. drowned out the background players.
i am glad you are out to save the music mo. keep up the good work!
michelle at 8:44AM on Sep 8th 2007
3. Don't forget Andrea Bocelli!
goike at 9:35AM on Sep 8th 2007
4. I saw Pavarotti live back in 2003, and I enjoyed every minute of it. (read more about in my blog) And as I expected, his death is just a 'glorified' bumper as you said. Of course, today’s mainstream media isn’t really focused on this larger than life legend of the opera. Only a handful of my personal friends who are around my age can say they’ve even heard of Pavarotti. It’s tragic that such beautiful music like Pavarotti’s rendition of ‘Nessun Dorma’ isn’t appreciated as much as it was. As such, it is paramount that we band together to save Anthony Tommasini’s job, or boycott the New York Times. Whatever’s more cost-effective.
As for ways to save his job, let’s look at some promisable tenors.
Yes, Andrea Bocelli has a lovely voice, and I’ve spouted numerous shower renditions of ‘Con Te Partiro’ because of him. Yet, Bocelli doesn’t seem to attract much of a crowd here, and the last time I saw him performing live on American television was on the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade on top of some wacky float. Hardly a fitting atmosphere for one of today’s better tenors. He definitely needs more recognition.
As an opera afficionado myself, I’ve been listening to two up and coming tenors. Russel Watson, nicknamed ‘The Voice’ is a British tenor who does a very goosebump inducing ‘Nessun Dorma’ and 'Funiculì, Funiculà' along with his own songs which have a bit of a ‘pop’ influence but are still rooted in harmonious opera styled music. Paul Potts, another British tenor who won Britain’s American Idol counterpart ‘Britain’s Got Talent’ and even made stubborn Simon Cowell quite delighted by his performances of ‘Nessun Dorma.’ I expect great things from him in the future.
Opera music is alive and well in Europe, as it’s always been. American opera has been slouching in this direction for awhile now considering not many Americans enjoy this style of music which is based on European culture and history. It takes a refined taste, but not so much to the point where you need to be Snooty McSnootagin to enjoy it. Still, I hope Anthony and other opera journalists around the states don’t lose their jobs over Luciano’s passing. There’s a whole big world out there full of great tenors, altos, baritones, and more. They’re just way too underappreciated here. Forget Domingo and Carreras, go for the new blood, otherwise, you mind’s well just be content listening to generation after generation of Britney Spears clones. Or worse, Little Jon and his East Side Boys. I shudder to think of such awful thoughts.
As Pavarotti sings ‘Ti Adoro!’
You friend, Blayze “Shaggy” O’Brien from the Bee
Blayze at 10:48AM on Sep 8th 2007
5. Don't forget Jessye Norman and Dame Kiri Te Kanawa!
It annoys me that he received far less coverage than Anna Nicole Smith, who clearly brought to a cultured world dry humping and diet pills.
sweetjulieblueyes at 11:23AM on Sep 8th 2007
6. Renee Fleming is definitely still around, and she's pretty fantastic. It's so sad that Pavarotti's death was hardly recognized. I never would've known if my mother hadn't actually told me that morning, because I can't remember seeing much if ANY coverage of it on the news.
If it's any consolation, my fellow opera majors and I (we go to a college for the fine arts) were definitely in mourning over this loss. I really should've learned more about him while he was alive.
D at 12:29PM on Sep 8th 2007
7.
Pavorotti's Voice is second to none. His voice always made me cry with his emotion being so powerful.
It is a crime for the media to create a self- fullfilling prophecy. By assuming that the death of a great tenor won;t generate enough ratings , By not giving him the media coverage he earned along with the other two tenors. the media makes sure his genius is commomorated by opera fans alone. What;s wrong with promoting opera among the general population. They are missing out on great gift to the world.
Unless a tenor shows up with out underwear. falls down stairs, solicits sex in a mensroom , slits their wrists, kills someone. Well the so called journalists will continue to perpetuate stories that are not worthy of the front page. I hope it's not too late to expect a fitting tribute. I have only seen the same clip on the news and nver heard a word from the other two tenors.
BRING ON THE TENORS ! STOP THE WAR!
marsha beckerman at 12:34PM on Sep 8th 2007
8. Thanks, all - Blayze, for your very cool first-person account.
Marsha, your suggestion that had Pavorotti not worn underwear he would have gotten more attention, is brilliant and hilarious.
Mo Rocca at 12:41PM on Sep 8th 2007
9.
Your frustration with soft news is well-shared, believe me, but surprising coming from someone who once stood on the mall at 30 Rock leading the Today show gang in 80's trivia. But I do see your point. There was a time when people could quote long passages of Scripture, whether it was their religion or not. Now basic references from the Bible are lost on most folks, but they can quote the Simpsons or Family Guy chapter and verse. As the providers of culture die off, our culture fades. People like Simon Cowell aren't helping either. On the surface, it looks like his Il Divo project is bringing culture to the acid-washed masses, but it's an illusion. Il Divo is so diluted, they amount to a boy band with an Italian accent. In the end, instead of inspiring fans to seek out the original inspiration, they become content with accepting what they're given as "culture."
Sorry for failing to bring the funny on this one. It's something I feel strongly about.
slackferno at 12:59PM on Sep 8th 2007
10.
FYI ; I was just watching pavarotti's funeral in Italy. I saw andrea bochelli singing. Also there is to be a tribute from his 4 year old daughter. I don;t know when it is to be aired, I just saw a snipet. Hopefully we can see the whole funeral,
marsha beckerman at 1:15PM on Sep 8th 2007
11. Aw Mo,
You really have to reconcile the culture clash between opera and the Republican administration.
I remember in the 80's when Queen and ELO were reviving opera into the mainstream.
We've pushed culture so far to the fringe that all we get is Amy Winehouse singing "No, No, No,."
Let's elect a pro-arts president and congress.
No Kimball joke here.
John Giza at 1:24PM on Sep 8th 2007
12. I would say constantly adding entries on what is going on in the classical music world today. While including the Two Tenors, also include other musicians in the classical genre, such as instrumentalists. Isaac Stern, one of the best violinists of all time, I believe feel into the same plight. He was a musical genius, his playing astounded all who came to listen. Yet when he died, little appreciation beyond the musical world was shown. Continuing in promoting the Two Tenors and other classical artists, is what all Tommasini can do. It's we (the viewers and listeners) who need to respond in a positive, appreciative way.
Game Theory for Applied Economics Nerd at 1:29PM on Sep 8th 2007
13. I consider, myself blessed with both: painting/musical abilities ... and happily prefers to play my own compositions. Naturally gifted individuals are greatly respected and those weened on the "PRELIMINARIES" of a [classical] trained foundation. As an essential requirement for artists like the GREAT Luciano Pavoratti ... may he "REST in Heavenly Peace."
Moh at 2:07PM on Sep 8th 2007
14. Además de dirigir decenas de obras sinfónicas de músicos chinos tales como He Luting, Ma Sicong, Luo Zhongrong, Wu Zuqiang y Chen Peixun, Li fue director de más de 20 obras chinas como la “Cantata del Río Amarillo” y el “Canto al Monte de Arboles”, que se ejecutaron en el exterior. Trabajó también con músicos de renombre internacional, como David Teodorovich Oistrakh, Yehudi Menuhin, Isacc Stern, Ma Youyou y Tatiana Nikolayeva, y con músicos chinos como Fu Cong, Liu Shikun, Shen Xiang, Guo Shuzhen, Hu Kun, Lü Siqing y Xue Wei.
John Giza at 2:09PM on Sep 8th 2007
15. ....pms: if 'pava' ( the kids today don't have time to use entire names or words!)...
was on TMZ he may have been BIG news, but only if he had some nice make-up on!
......and besides...'boce' is still alive...your only newsworthy when you kick the bucket...and as the pro-mo said~only a bumper.
i miss the 1960's commercials too.
they insulted everyone with love!
best regards,
m
mimi at 3:52PM on Sep 8th 2007