-- America provides an amazingly good life for the ordinary guy. Rich people live well everywhere. But what distinguishes America is that it provides an impressively high standard of living for the "common man." We now live in a country where construction workers regularly pay $4 for a nonfat latte, where maids drive nice cars and where plumbers take their families on vacation to Europe.
Indeed, newcomers to the United States are struck by the amenities enjoyed by "poor" people. This fact was dramatized in the 1980s when CBS television broadcast a documentary, "People Like Us," intended to show the miseries of the poor during an ongoing recession. The Soviet Union also broadcast the documentary, with a view to embarrassing the Reagan administration. But by the testimony of former Soviet leaders, it had the opposite effect. Ordinary people across the Soviet Union saw that the poorest Americans have TV sets, microwave ovens and cars. They arrived at the same perception that I witnessed in an acquaintance of mine from Bombay who has been unsuccessfully trying to move to the United States. I asked him, "Why are you so eager to come to America?" He replied, "I really want to live in a country where the poor people are fat."
-- America offers more opportunity and social mobility than any other country, including the countries of Europe. America is the only country that has created a population of "self-made tycoons." Only in America could Pierre Omidyar, whose parents are Iranian and who grew up in Paris, have started a company like eBay. Only in America could Vinod Khosla, the son of an Indian army officer, become a leading venture capitalist, the shaper of the technology industry, and a billionaire to boot. Admittedly tycoons are not typical, but no country has created a better ladder than America for people to ascend from modest circumstances to success.
-- Work and trade are respectable in America. Historically most cultures have despised the merchant and the laborer, regarding the former as vile and corrupt and the latter as degraded and vulgar. Some cultures, such as that of ancient Greece and medieval Islam, even held that it is better to acquire things through plunder than through trade or contract labor. But the American founders altered this moral hierarchy. They established a society in which the life of the businessman, and of the people who worked for him, would be a noble calling. In the American view, there is nothing vile or degraded about serving your customers either as a CEO or as a waiter. The ordinary life of production and supporting a family is more highly valued in the United States than in any other country. America is the only country in the world where we call the waiter "sir," as if he were a knight.
-- America has achieved greater social equality than any other society. True, there are large inequalities of income and wealth in America. In purely economic terms, Europe is more egalitarian. But Americans are socially more equal than any other people, and this is unaffected by economic disparities. Alexis de Tocqueville noticed this egalitarianism a century and a half ago and it is, if anything, more prevalent today. For all his riches, Bill Gates could not approach the typical American and say, "Here's a $100 bill. I'll give it to you if you kiss my feet." Most likely, the person would tell Gates to go to hell! The American view is that the rich guy may have more money, but he isn't in any fundamental sense better than anyone else.
-- People live longer, fuller lives in America. Although protesters rail against the American version of technological capitalism at trade meetings around the world, in reality the American system has given citizens many more years of life, and the means to live more intensely and actively. In 1900, the life expectancy in America was around 50 years; today, it is more than 75 years. Advances in medicine and agriculture are mainly responsible for the change. This extension of the life span means more years to enjoy life, more free time to devote to a good cause, and more occasions to do things with the grandchildren. In many countries, people who are old seem to have nothing to do: they just wait to die. In America the old are incredibly vigorous, and people in their seventies pursue the pleasures of life, including remarriage and sexual gratification, with a zeal that I find unnerving.
-- In America the destiny of the young is not given to them, but created by them. Not long ago, I asked myself, "What would my life have been like if I had never come to the United States?" If I had remained in India, I would probably have lived my whole life within a five-mile radius of where I was born. I would undoubtedly have married a woman of my identical religious and socioeconomic background. I would almost certainly have become a medical doctor, or an engineer, or a computer programmer. I would have socialized entirely within my ethic community. I would have a whole set of opinions that could be predicted in advance; indeed, they would not be very different from what my father believed, or his father before him. In sum, my destiny would to a large degree have been given to me.
In America, I have seen my life take a radically different course. In college I became interested in literature and politics, and I resolved to make a career as a writer. I married a woman whose ancestry is English, French, Scotch-Irish, and German. In my twenties I found myself working as a policy analyst in the White House, even though I was not an American citizen. No other country, I am sure, would have permitted a foreigner to work in its inner citadel of government.
In most countries in the world, your fate and your identity are handed to you; in America, you determine them for yourself. America is a country where you get to write the script of your own life. Your life is like a blank sheet of paper, and you are the artist. This notion of being the architect of your own destiny is the incredibly powerful idea that is behind the worldwide appeal of America. Young people especially find irresistible the prospect of authoring the narrative of their own lives.
-- America has gone further than any other society in establishing equality of rights. There is nothing distinctively American about slavery or bigotry. Slavery has existed in virtually every culture, and xenophobia, prejudice and discrimination are worldwide phenomena. Western civilization is the only civilization to mount a principled campaign against slavery; no country expended more treasure and blood to get rid of slavery than the United States. While racism remains a problem, this country has made strenuous efforts to eradicate discrimination, even to the extent of enacting policies that give legal preference in university admissions, jobs, and government contracts to members of minority groups. Such policies remain controversial, but the point is that it is extremely unlikely that a racist society would have permitted such policies in the first place. And surely African Americans like Jesse Jackson are vastly better off living in America than they would be if they were to live in, say, Ethiopia or Somalia.
-- America has found a solution to the problem of religious and ethnic conflict that continues to divide and terrorize much of the world. Visitors to places like New York are amazed to see the way in which Serbs and Croatians, Sikhs and Hindus, Irish Catholics and Irish Protestants, Jews and Palestinians, all seem to work and live together in harmony. How is this possible when these same groups are spearing each other and burning each other's homes in so many places in the world?
The American answer is twofold. First, separate the spheres of religion and government so that no religion is given official preference but all are free to practice their faith as they wish. Second, do not extend rights to racial or ethnic groups but only to individuals; in this way, all are equal in the eyes of the law, opportunity is open to anyone who can take advantage of it, and everybody who embraces the American way of life can "become American."
Of course there are exceptions to these core principles, even in America. Racial preferences are one such exception, which explains why they are controversial. But in general, America is the only country in the world that extends full membership to outsiders. The typical American could come to India, live for 40 years, and take Indian citizenship. But he could not "become Indian." He wouldn't see himself that way, nor would most Indians see him that way. In America, by contrast, hundreds of millions have come from far-flung shores and over time they, or at least their children, have in a profound and full sense "become American."
-- America has the kindest, gentlest foreign policy of any great power in world history. Critics of the United States are likely to react to this truth with sputtering outrage. They will point to long-standing American support for a Latin or Middle Eastern despot, or the unjust internment of the Japanese during World War II, or America's reluctance to impose sanctions on South Africa's apartheid regime, or America's occupation of Iraq. However one feels about these particular cases, let us concede to the critics the point that America is not always in the right.
What the critics leave out is the other side of the ledger. Twice in the 20th century, the United States saved the world -- first from the Nazi threat, then from Soviet totalitarianism. What would have been the world's fate if America had not existed? After destroying Germany and Japan in World War II, the United States proceeded to rebuild both countries, and today they are American allies. Now we are attempting to do the same thing in Afghanistan and Iraq. Consider, too, how magnanimous the United States has been to the former Soviet Union after its victory in the Cold War. For the most part America is an abstaining superpower; it shows no real interest in conquering and subjugating the rest of the world. (Imagine how the Soviets would have acted if they had won the Cold War.) On occasion the United States intervenes to overthrow a tyrannical regime or to halt massive human rights abuses in another country, but it never stays to rule that country. In Grenada, Haiti and Bosnia, the United States got in and then it got out. Moreover, when America does get into a war, as in Iraq, its troops are supremely careful to avoid targeting civilians and to minimize collateral damage. Even as America bombed the Taliban infrastructure and hideouts, U.S. planes dropped food to avert hardship and starvation of Afghan civilians. What other country does these things?
-- America, the freest nation on earth, is also the most virtuous nation on earth. This point seems counterintuitive, given the amount of conspicuous vulgarity, vice and immorality in America. Some Islamic radicals argue that their regimes are morally superior to the United States because they seek to foster virtue among the citizens. Virtue, these radicals argue, is a higher principle than liberty.
Indeed it is. And let us admit that in a free society, freedom will frequently be used badly. Freedom, by definition, includes the freedom to do good or evil, to act nobly or basely. But if freedom brings out the worst in people, it also brings out the best. The millions of Americans who live decent, praiseworthy lives desire our highest admiration because they have opted for the good when the good is not the only available option. Even amid the temptations of a rich and free society, they have remained on the straight path. Their virtue has special luster because it is freely chosen.
By contrast, the societies that many Islamic radicals seek would eliminate the possibility of virtue. If the supply of virtue is insufficient in a free society like America, it is almost nonexistent in an unfree society like Iran's. The reason is that coerced virtues are not virtues at all. Consider the woman who is required to wear a veil. There is no modesty in this, because she is being compelled. Compulsion cannot produce virtue, it can only produce the outward semblance of virtue. Thus a free society like America's is not merely more prosperous, more varied, more peaceful, and more tolerant -- it is also morally superior to the theocratic and authoritarian regimes that America's enemies advocate.
"To make us love our country," Edmund Burke once said, "our country ought to be lovely." Burke's point is that we should love our country not just because it is ours, but also because it is good. America is far from perfect, and there is lots of room for improvement. In spite of its flaws, however, American life as it is lived today is the best life that our world has to offer. Ultimately America is worthy of our love and sacrifice because, more than any other society, it makes possible the good life, and the life that is good.




Reader Comments ( Page 1 of 82)
1. well let me be the first to comment and say "only in america" yes we have have our share of naysayers and they are quick to point the finger even as they drive their suv's and we have our left and right wingers who are always at odds. but at least here in america you have a chance, which is better than most places. this morning my wife was telling me about some of the children she teaches and how their dad was beaten very badly and robbed by three black men. the teachers at her scholl immediatley took up a collection of food and money to help. ech class grade "adopted" on of the 4 kids to make sure they would have a decent christmas and they pooled together and bought a mexican style thanksgiving since these kids were mexican. now inside this story is alot thats wrong,namely why a hard working family would be senselessly robbed. also, there is alot thats right because look how the community mobilized and responded. this is america at its best and its worst. its like the biblical picture of the wheat and the tares. there is always going to be friction between good and evil,but here in america good seems to triumph at the end of the day. because at heart we are a christian culture with values that esteem life. go dinesh, i am glad america has room for another success story such as yours!!! only in america friends and foes!!
brian at 12:44PM on Nov 21st 2007
2. Oooo...another free shill for a crappy D'idiot book.
But for someone who gushes about tolerence, this bozo is as INtolerant as they come. if you're not a het-christian-republican, then you're just not a good person, according to DD.
TIM at 12:54PM on Nov 21st 2007
3. Without a doubt the best article I have read from Dinesh. Thank you for writing it. I believe it came straight from your heart.
Happy Thanksgiving.
Bill
dungal1 at 1:20PM on Nov 21st 2007
4. Yes, America was, is, and hopefully will continue to be great! But it's our willingness to correct mistakes, and right wrongs that have & will continue to make us that way. Patting ones-self on the back is as useless and tiring as unjustified criticism and self loathing!
Robert E. Quillen at 1:21PM on Nov 21st 2007
5. DD makes some valid points. My dad was an immigrant from Slovakia. Although he lived in abject poverty in West Virginia, it was still better than his homeland.
HOWEVER:
(Hint: We are just above Slovenia.)
World Health Organization's ranking of the World's Health Systems (2007 report)
Rank Country
1 France
2 Italy
3 San Marino
4 Andorra
5 Malta
6 Singapore
7 Spain
8 Oman
9 Austria
10 Japan
11 Norway
12 Portugal
13 Monaco
14 Greece
15 Iceland
16 Luxembourg
17 Netherlands
18 United Kingdom
19 Ireland
20 Switzerland
21 Belgium
22 Colombia
23 Sweden
24 Cyprus
25 Germany
26 Saudi Arabia
27 United Arab Emirates
28 Israel
29 Morocco
30 Canada
31 Finland
32 Australia
33 Chile
34 Denmark
35 Dominica
36 Costa Rica
37 United States of America
38 Slovenia
39 Cuba
40 Brunei
41 New Zealand
42 Bahrain
43 Croatia
44 Qatar
45 Kuwait
46 Barbados
47 Thailand
48 Czech Republic
49 Malaysia
50 Poland
51 Dominican Republic
52 Tunisia
53 Jamaica
54 Venezuela
55 Albania
56 Seychelles
57 Paraguay
58 South Korea
59 Senegal
60 Philippines
61 Mexico
62 Slovakia
63 Egypt
64 Kazakhstan
65 Uruguay
66 Hungary
67 Trinidad and Tobago
68 Saint Lucia
69 Belize
70 Turkey
71 Nicaragua
72 Belarus
73 Lithuania
74 Saint Vincent and the Grenadines
75 Argentina
76 Sri Lanka
77 Estonia
78 Guatemala
79 Ukraine
80 Solomon Islands
81 Algeria
82 Palau
83 Jordan
84 Mauritius
85 Grenada
86 Antigua and Barbuda
87 Libya
88 Bangladesh
89 Macedonia
90 Bosnia-Herzegovina
91 Lebanon
92 Indonesia
93 Iran
94 Bahamas
95 Panama
96 Fiji
97 Benin
98 Nauru
99 Romania
100 Saint Kitts and Nevis
101 Moldova
102 Bulgaria
103 Iraq
104 Armenia
105 Latvia
106 Yugoslavia
107 Cook Islands
108 Syria
109 Azerbaijan
110 Suriname
111 Ecuador
112 India
113 Cape Verde
114 Georgia
115 El Salvador
116 Tonga
117 Uzbekistan
118 Comoros
119 Samoa
120 Yemen
121 Niue
122 Pakistan
123 Micronesia
124 Bhutan
125 Brazil
126 Bolivia
127 Vanuatu
128 Guyana
129 Peru
130 Russia
131 Honduras
132 Burkina Faso
133 Sao Tome and Principe
134 Sudan
135 Ghana
136 Tuvalu
137 Ivory Coast
138 Haiti
139 Gabon
140 Kenya
141 Marshall Islands
142 Kiribati
143 Burundi
144 China
145 Mongolia
146 Gambia
147 Maldives
148 Papua New Guinea
149 Uganda
150 Nepal
151 Kyrgystan
152 Togo
153 Turkmenistan
154 Tajikistan
155 Zimbabwe
156 Tanzania
157 Djibouti
158 Eritrea
159 Madagascar
160 Vietnam
161 Guinea
162 Mauritania
163 Mali
164 Cameroon
165 Laos
166 Congo
167 North Korea
168 Namibia
169 Botswana
170 Niger
171 Equatorial Guinea
172 Rwanda
173 Afghanistan
174 Cambodia
175 South Africa
176 Guinea-Bissau
177 Swaziland
178 Chad
179 Somalia
180 Ethiopia
181 Angola
182 Zambia
183 Lesotho
184 Mozambique
185 Malawi
186 Liberia
187 Nigeria
188 Democratic Republic of the Congo
189 Central African Republic
190 Myanmar
AND for average longevity, we rank 27th in the world. All of Europe is ahead of us.
Linda at 1:39PM on Nov 21st 2007
6. MORMANS BELIEVE THEY CAN BECOME GODS!
They also believe the Earth is 4,000 years old!
They believe in Noah's Ark, Adam & Eve, & that
the 'Garden Of Eden'is in Missouri!
Devoid of Logic, Reason, & Rationality!
Can you think of a better reason NOT To VOTE
for Mitt Romney?
Chandler Yergin at 1:43PM on Nov 21st 2007
7. We all need to be thankful to God for
the freedoms we have here. We also
need to be thankful, all of us have a
right to speak our minds.
I would like to see people start to
be more for a united states though. I
would like to see people start to think
a little more before they speak. We
need to find ways to bring this country
back together as a people and not use
a political stance to push us apart.
United we stand and divided we fall.
Lets all start looking at ways which
will help us unite, especially against
the high prices of oil, diesel, gas,
heating oil and electricity.
We need to start concentrating on us
making electricity and getting away
from oil. We can heal the nation but
need to band together if we are to
make a difference. If not for us,
then for the children. They need to
see us work together as a people so
they too can have hope in what we
leave for them as a future.
William Ehlert at 1:44PM on Nov 21st 2007
8. Addendum:
That last statistic was from
'Healthy People 2000'. They surveyed the 36 industrialized nations.
Since then, 10,000,000 more Americans have lost or don't have any health insurance (Now at 47 million)
Linda at 1:44PM on Nov 21st 2007
9. FUNDAMENTALISTS ARE LIVING PROOF OF EVOLUTION!
Two separate distinct & by themselves INERT,
egg & sperm cells, meet, combine, replicate,
& some EVOLVE into Ignorant, Arrogant
Fundamentalists!
Chandler Yergin at 1:47PM on Nov 21st 2007
10. can't you raving, raging people find something to be positive about? if you don't like the health care, the politics, or whatever i mean france is waiting and delta is ready when you are. please leave if you don't like but quit being such a distraction.you naysayers are annoying
brian at 1:52PM on Nov 21st 2007
11. At posts 369 & 372 Linda writes,
"The western cultures of Maya and Aztec were flourishing at that time. Granted, they were a little bloodthirsty. But both groups had an awesome culture. Oh, and the oriental and indian cultures were flourishing. It's just western culture that was in the 'dark ages'. Guess why."
Hello Linda:
Maybe you didn't understand my response to fabio but the point I was making about "dark ages" applied to ALL cultures/empires. In other words, all the known cultures of mankind have had periods of greatness and decline. ALL. So what is your guess about that?
Secondly, I see that you have no response to my reply to your post(s) where you did not completely state the Law of C of E in its entirety. Just to remind you:
--law of Conservation of Energy states that energy cannot be created or destroyed; IT CAN ONLY BE CHANGED FROM ONE FORM TO ANOTHER--
How do you reconcile the teenee-tiny problem of what caused the "state-change" to occur? As a scientist you well know, nothing just happens.
ManOfMettl at 1:57PM on Nov 21st 2007
12. Obviously there is a critical mass that precluded the 'big bang'
Doesn't that make sense?
Linda at 2:03PM on Nov 21st 2007
13. Oh, and Brian: I've been hearing that 'love it or leave it' since the 60's.
I have been fighting for health insurance for ALL Americans for as long as I've been a nurse. But conservatives don't see that as a right for americans.
You can swallow all of DD's stuff, or you can find out for yourself where this country needs to improve. We are a JOKE to the industrialized nations in many ways. Especially for that war mongering Bush
Linda at 2:05PM on Nov 21st 2007
14. How come you never hear:
"ALLAH BLESS AMERICA"
???
stuart joshua at 2:06PM on Nov 21st 2007
15. Well, well, well......so, much the same as the atheists coming to your "news" blog for their daily correction, you came to our great country for your correction.
While I wish that you were somewhere else, I am glad that you have been corrected, but don't you think you are divisive and mean-spirited to those whose beliefs you do not embrace....on a daily basis...and thus you go against one of the main tenets about which you wrote?
stuart joshua at 2:07PM on Nov 21st 2007