Today on the show we were talking about how Fox News was questioning Barack Obama's patriotism and how I thought he didn't do a great job of debunking stories that go the heart of this charge. The problem is that by answering the question he feeds into the question. He should turn the whole premise of the question on its head.
Obama shouldn't talk about whether he is or is not patriotic. He should talk about how he is clearly the most patriotic candidate in the race:
Young Turks on You Tube
Young Turk's Blog Roll
Featured Bloggers
| Ada Calhoun | |
| Ben Greenman | |
| Dinesh D'Souza | |
| Jeff Hoard | |
| Mo Rocca | |
| Young Turks |
RSS Feeds
Resources
The Young Turks
Report
The Young Turks, hosted by Cenk Uygur and Ben Mankiewicz, airs on Air America Radio... read more
Obama Should Claim to be More Patriotic Than McCain
Top Tags
Most Popular Stories
Most Commented On News Bloggers
Recent Comments
- Sheryl on Obama and the Reagan Doctrine
- Antonio Apostol Jr. on Obama and the Reagan Doctrine
- andreawalker419 on Breastfeeding an Eight-Year-Old?
- bob on Parents Put Baby Up for Sale on eBay
- Darin on Are Father-Daughter Purity Balls Really Christian?
- Clif Kuplen on Sarah and Katie: The Secret Language of Popular Girls
- erm god is fake duh... on The Top Five GodTube Arguments Against Evolution
Top News Headlines
Ada Calhoun |
Ben Greenman |
Dinesh D'Souza |
Jeff Hoard |
Mo Rocca |
The Young Turks |



Reader Comments ( Page 1 of 3)
1. Yeah, Obama should attack a war hero as unpatriotic. Oh, that'll work. Earlier this week, Obama's "spiritual mentor" describes him as a mere politician, and now you suggest that he attack a war hero as unpatriotic. With friends like these..
emelpe at 8:30AM on Apr 29th 2008
2. Hey chink,
This race baiter is running for president of America, yet identifies himself as "african-American". Doesn't sound patriotic to me. Sounds sympathetic to his "peeps".
jscotthhi at 8:37AM on Apr 29th 2008
3. While nothing amazes me anymore about the silliness that passes for political analysis, just when I think you have reached the lowest level of stupidity you come out with something even dumber. You have been successful in making Bill Maher, another hack, seem like Edward R Murrow.
Eric at 9:45AM on Apr 29th 2008
4. Hey there Big Guy,
I listened to your pitch and only bought a small piece of it. I for one have had enough of Obama, his wife and pastor talking about patriotism.
And as far as his association with Bill Ayers, the terrorist that went around setting off IED's in Washington D.C and NYC in the 70's ...well, Obama has said they only sat on one Board together, they only live in the same neighborhood, their children played together and when Ayers was setting off those IED's, Obama was only 8.....so what the crap!
Willet at 10:08AM on Apr 29th 2008
5. Cenk
Rev. J-Wright claims he is more patriotic than Big Dick Cheney because he was in the Marines for six years.
Hey J-Wright: Benedict Arnold was a General in the Continental Army before switching sides, Timothy McVeigh was a Decorated Veteran of Gulf War I and Lee Harvey Oswald was a Marine sharpshooter. And your point is?
Paul Sparcello at 10:19AM on Apr 29th 2008
6. You go ahead and vote for the racist whose self-hatred of the white blood running through his own veins has caused him to be that way because of your own guilt because of things your white ancestors did MANY years ago in this country and I'll vote for someone who is actually proud to be an American and qualifed to do the job. I wouldn't vote for any racist whether white, black or purple. We need a leader who will represent ALL of us, not just the half of his gene pool that he embraces.
hlaredzz at 10:28AM on Apr 29th 2008
7. You know, I don't think it is possible for you to suck up to Obama any more than you already have. I am confident that if he went on television and executed a puppy, you would say the puppy deserved it.
Hunter at 10:30AM on Apr 29th 2008
8. Just a few of the UN-Patriotic actions of Obama
Obama bowed at the alter of unrepentant domestic terrorist Ayres/Dorn for their blessing to run for political office.
Obama profited from political corruption involving land deals with the Rezko's while his constituency was living in horrid conditions created by Rezko and Drug Deals.
Obama has tried to destroy the Second Amendment by funding Anti-Gun proposals to the tune of $18,000,000.00 while serving as an activist member of the board of directors of the rabidly anti-gun Joyce Foundations.
Paul Sparcello at 11:04AM on Apr 29th 2008
9. Some posts have stated that attacking "a war hero as unpatriotic" is bound to fail. How soon we forget - that's just what Bush et al. successfully accomplished in 2004. Samuel Johnson said it all in 1775 - "Patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel". Patriotism is putting selfish needs behind the needs of the nation. It isn't false bravado or mindless support for illogical and/or failed policies.
Steve at 12:39PM on Apr 29th 2008
10. Sincere question that came up because of a post on patriotism: How many 2nd amendment defenders out there support Constitutional amendments defining marriage, proscribing flag burning, or prohibiting abortion?
What is my point? The original Constitution used 2/3 of the number of slaves as part of the formula to determine representation in Congress. Because the Constitution is a living document, the founders provided a process of amendment to account for differing perspectives in the future.
Steve at 1:41PM on Apr 29th 2008
11. Hey good luck with that one Cenk. That may fly in Libworld but nowhere else. A picture is worth a thousand words and the picture of Obama during the National Anthem( or was it the Pledge of Allegiance)is all the Republicans need . If they're smart, they"ll post it every day.
IRONBLUEEYES at 1:49PM on Apr 29th 2008
12. Just a few facts. You are all entitled to your opinions but not to your own facts. First, Lee Harvey Oswald shot marksman, the lowest qualifying ranking, not sharpshooter, the middle rank for shooters. Second, the Constitution includes the 3/5 Compromise, where for representation purposes, only three out of every five slaves would be counted in apportioning Congressional seats not 2/3 as Steve would have it. Sorry, Steve, you played hookey that day.
longwalker at 1:59PM on Apr 29th 2008
13. dear Longwalker - Sorry about the 2/3 3/5 mix up - but that diversion from the point of the comment doesn't change the question.
Steve at 2:13PM on Apr 29th 2008
14. Steve : Glad to see you have read Samuel Johnson. For your information "benefit of clergy" was the first refuge.
In my opinion, what John F. Kerry did in "Winter Soldier" and, later, in Paris with the North Vietnamese makes Benedict Arnold look like a peer of Washington.
longwalker at 2:37PM on Apr 29th 2008
15. McCain is not a war hero. He's a victim of the horrible war crime of torture but he is not a hero. A hero is someone who saves the lives of others. He has done nothing to earn the title of "hero". Many soldiers have been held and tortured and no one refers to them as heroes.
Lee at 3:08PM on Apr 29th 2008