Yes, it was a great speech, possibly the highlight of the Republican convention. And yes, it was the climax of a big day for the GOP. First Romney and then Huckabee made their effective case against Obama and Biden. Then Giuliani came in as the Mafia Man to rough up Obama, a bruising he delivered with obvious relish. I would not have thought Palin could top these three seasoned veterans, but she did. It doesn't really matter how McCain does; the Republicans are off and running.
Commentators have noted that Palin spoke with aplomb. The liberals had sought to portray her as a bungler and a problem pick, akin to George H.W. Bush's selection of Dan Quayle. But the attacks created for Palin a great opportunity. All she had to show was that she was not the small-town nitwit of Democratic propaganda. Palin also demonstrated that she could mount a devastating attack on Obama--basically a "community organizer" who knows how to talk a slick game--without coming across as mean-spirited. This is a real art, to know how to punch with a smile. As commentator Fred Barnes said later, this is not an easy skill to learn. Palin didn't really learn it; she is a natural.
What struck me most about Palin, however, was not her pungent one-liners or her savoir faire. Rather, it was her girlish innocence, her unexpected candor and small-town charm. Palin came across as a really wholesome all-American, a real contrast with all the men in the race. Both by her words and her style, she contrasted herself with both Biden and Obama. Biden is basically a mediocre fellow (he graduated in the bottom 10 percent of his law school class, where he was found guilty of plagiarism) whose only original ideas have been terrible ideas, like carving Iraq into small pieces. He is also a product of the back-slapping Washington D.C. establishment. Republicans haven't bothered to attack Biden because he isn't worth attacking. By contrast, Democrats are going crazy over Palin because she scares them.
Even Palin's so-called problems highlight her normalcy. So her husband had a DUI conviction twenty years ago. First of all it wasn't her, it was her husband. Second, how does this compare with Obama, who was snorting cocaine twenty years ago? The media, with its familiar one-sidedness, has been commending Obama's "honesty" over his drug use while blasting Palin for her husband's irresponsible driving. Then Palin's daughter got pregnant at 17: apparently the "family values" didn't entirely get through. Even so, Bristol and the boyfriend are keeping the baby and getting married. So responsibility wins out after all.
By contrast, Obama said he wanted to preserve abortion rights because if his daughters got pregnant one day he wouldn't want them to be "punished" with a child. (Let's be glad that Obama's mom didn't think this way because if she had at the age of 18, Obama wouldn't be around today.) Even Palin's alleged action to fire the state trooper who split with her sister and then harassed her is precisely the kind of action that most Americans would take in a similar situation. While Obama is a cunning Chicago pol who has played his rhetoric and his machine connections to rise through the ranks, Palin remains authenticially all-American with ordinary and recognizable problems.
The problem for the Republicans is that many Americans have become jaded about them. McCain's maverick reputation helps, but it doesn't alter this reality. Palin, on the other hand, is a completely fresh face. I predict she will appeal not only to Christian conservatives but also to working-class independents, male and female, who see in her the promise of real reform. Palin offers change, but this does not take the form of warmed-over socialism. Instead, it is change in congruence with traditional American values. I don't know if an unspoiled person like Palin can actually clean out the Augean stables in the nation's capital, but she does seem determined to try. She is the new star of this political race and already she has altered the whole equation.



Reader Comments ( Page 44 of 44)
646. ATHEIST
Paul wrote letters to various churches, usually answering questions he was asked.
Paul didn't write any books.
go through the letters of Paul and write down every time he mentions "resurrection." For the most part, he's NOT talking about Jesus.
William Hays at 10:09PM on Sep 8th 2008
647. tell ya, republicans don't get irony but they do it well (courtesy of St. Brian)
Tim at 9:51PM on Sep 8th 2008
Hello Clif,
Like the Brooks and Dunn song goes You can take the girl out of the country but you can't take the country out of the girl.
It's nice to see that you are trying to vary your usual posting. Shows a little more creativity. keep up the good work, may be people will think that "tim" is someone that agrees with your philosophy.
M2D5 at 8:07AM on Sep 9th 2008
648. GHB post 424 - Talking about name calling? Now if that isn't the pot calling the kettle black.
Man_in_Wilderness at 9:43AM on Sep 9th 2008
649. ryan post 638 - try to migrate to Mexico, and see how they respond.
Man_in_Wilderness at 9:45AM on Sep 9th 2008
650. MIW: "ryan post 638 - try to migrate to Mexico, and see how they respond"
I don't see how this is relevant to my point.
Ryan Anderson at 10:36AM on Sep 9th 2008
651. Why would you want someone normal? You're not looking for someone to go to the bar with, you're looking for someone to lead your damned country. That person should be EXCEPTIONAL, not ordinary.
Brian Hogg at 6:15PM on Sep 10th 2008
652. Ryan post 646 - My apologies, I have been very busy. The relevance is that migration doesn't wash. Illegal is illegal, obey the laws. (period) If you or I wish to migrate to Mexico, Canada, Germany, or wherever they have laws, obey the laws go through their immigration process. We are asking that illegal immigrants be forced to leave, or go through the legal process just like everyone else.
Man_in_Wilderness at 7:06PM on Sep 10th 2008
653. Palin really got the best of all worlds as she was unvieled. She did a great job on the speech but was it of her doing. I think not. She is a new face and the republicans need to protect her is overwhelming.
Beautifully done and if it leads to 4 more years of the same ole thing, who are we going to blame it on.
Not me as I am not convinced that anything will change with a same ole republican admin.
Ken Brisendine at 2:36PM on Sep 11th 2008
654. Ken post 652 - And you think it will change with the dems? Let me also remind you on this day, if the Clinton administration had done their job 9/11 would not have occured.
Man_in_Wilderness at 9:46PM on Sep 11th 2008
655. "Ken post 652 - And you think it will change with the dems? Let me also remind you on this day, if the Clinton administration had done their job 9/11 would not have occured."
MIW,
Amazing. Nice try on the deflection.
Let's take it back further Mr. Divisive.
If Reagan had done his job in Lebanon, there would never have been a 9/11.
Botts at 11:00PM on Sep 11th 2008
656. Response to Pliny:
"Then there is the fact that his candidacy can't help but inspire a lot of kids out there..." It's interesting to note that 1/3 of our youth are NOT out there because they have been killed before they had a chance to live---because of "Rights" that Obama champions.
jdep at 2:27AM on Sep 14th 2008
657. Go to my blog. The power of Christ commands you!
http://saintbrianthegodless.blogspot.com/
Saint Brian the Godless at 3:47AM on Sep 16th 2008