Opie and Anthony just
got in trouble on XM Satellite Radio for having an open conversation about sex with Laura Bush, Condoleezza Rice and Queen Elizabeth. Apparently there was
violent imagery involved as well. That part is unacceptable. I'm not going to get into what the ramifications of that should be and if an apology fixes the situation.
So, this is not a judgment on XM's actions in this case, since there was a different number of issues involved. For the rest of this post, I will discuss just the sexual part of the conversation, not the part involving violence, which has a different standard -- and should.
I want to make two points about open sexual talk on-air. First, context matters. They are on satellite radio and I view that as a free speech zone. There is a rating system for parents and parental blocking system on XM. Those are responsible precautions. Because of that and the fact that it is a for-pay system, they should be allowed to have a very, wide range on any and all discussions. They can be completely racist, sexist or any other damn thing they please. As long as they don't advocate outright violence in a way that is clearly illegal, I think it is imperative that we have places where people can speak completely freely.
You never know where speech takes you sometimes. And what seems like horribly offensive speech might open up very necessary dialogue and allow you to talk about issues that are buried and not discussed in the open nearly enough. We need to have a place where adults talk without fearing offense. If you are offended, be an adult and turn the channel.
We can't censor everything based on the lowest common denominator of sensitivity. This applies to conservative thought, liberal thought or completely non-political thought. You don't need the concept of freedom of speech to protect pleasant speech, you need it to protect speech that might be and is offensive to some.
Second, talking about sex with public officials should be completely inside the bounds on satellite radio. We used to do it all the time when we were exclusively on Sirius Satellite Radio (we are now in national syndication on local radio stations and XM satellite radio). We would often ask questions like (don't read further if you are easily offended by the idea of sex): Who would you rather do: Laura Bush or Condoleezza Rice?