As John McCain consolidates his position as the leader to secure the Republican nomination, many conservatives are expressing anxiety that McCain is not "one of us." Some of the shriller voices even denounce McCain as an impostor.
This seems strange. If McCain is not a real conservative, how is he winning races where conservatives dominate the voting ranks of the GOP?
Basically there is a split between what some leading conservative pundits think, and what rank-and-file conservatives think. The pundits detest McCain in part because of issues but mostly because of temperament. McCain is reviled for his campaign finance reform, and for expressing reservations about the Bush tax cuts, and for supporting immigration amnesty.
McCain's greatest failing, however, in these folks' eyes, is that he is a wild horse who doesn't move along the predictable conservative track. He is suspiciously popular with the mainstream media. He courts independent voters. Horror of horrors, the man said he doesn't listen to Rush Limbaugh.
On the big issues, however, McCain seems pretty conservative. Actually I suspect he's more conservative than Bush. He has consistently been with Bush, or to the right of him, on the Iraq war. No one can doubt McCain's commitment to a muscular foreign policy.
McCain may not be as zealous a tax-cutter as Bush, but it's safe to say he won't be as profligate a spender. McCain is an old-school fiscal conservative who only wants to spend when there's money in the bank. Since when it that a vice among conservatives?
Finally McCain is solid on the social issues that matter most to conservatives. His votes have been reliably pro-life, and he wants to appoint strict constructionist judges like John Roberts and Sam Alito to the Supreme Court. McCain supports tolerance for gays but opposes gay marriage.
I like both Romney and Huckabee, and if Obama is the Democratic nominee, then anything can happen. But if, as expected, the Democrats go with Hillary Clinton, then the Republicans would be wise to put up someone of equal stature. The last time the GOP fooled around with Hillary, the result was a disaster.
Remember Rick Lazio? As the GOP's candidate in the New York senate race, Lazio was an attractive and energetic right-winger, but Hillary badly trounced him. McCain is quite clearly in Hillary's league, and I suspect that he would be stronger against Hillary than either Romney or Huckabee.
It's time for conservatives to stop throwing tantrums over McCain and start thinking about how best to hold the White House in November.
14. My first husband always sat down and I saw it as effeminate. My present husband and two sons do not, and how I wish that they did!!! :)
Sit Down! at 1:41PM on Jul 13th 2007