35 Years After Roe v. Wade

By Justin Paulette
Jan 22nd 2008 8:11AM

Filed Under:e2008 President, Abortion

"Supreme Court Settles Abortion Issue."

- The New York Times, January 23, 1973


It didn't quite turn out as the Times predicted. Today marks the 35th anniversary of Roe v. Wade, the Supreme Court decision that "settled" the abortion debate by sweeping aside the laws of all 50 states and imposing a federal abortion mandate to protect women's rights on the nation.


In contrast with the Times' hopeful headline, hundreds of thousands will arrive in Washington, D.C. today for the annual "March for Life," and every presidential candidate will undoubtedly speak to the occassion. Democrats will laud the progress of women's reproductive rights and privacy rights in general, while Republicans will mourn 40 million lost babies and reproach a "run-away" judiciary. Each candidate will attempt to fully exploit the opportunity to rally the base and churn up support.




Giuliani will prove the lone exception, being at odds with his party on the issue of abortion. The mayor would be wise to tuck tail and keep low today. If cornered, Giuliani will likely state his consistency on women's rights ... and immediately change the conversation to the economy or 9-11. Also, McCain must tread lightly, as many conservatives harbor a deep distrust of the maverick senator. However, McCain ought to take advantage of this opportunity to reiterate his pro-life stance - particularly as he will not be subject to rebuttal or uncomfortable scrutiny of his nuanced position.


The "abortion debate" is generally synonymous with "the debate over Roe v. Wade" - and this social-legal merging is not coincidental. Dubbed an "exercise of raw judicial power" by Justice White in his dissenting opinion, the ruling elicited outrage both among social conservatives (believing the procedure to be murder) as well as limited-government federalists (shocked that the Court's emergence as a super-legislature dictating medical science and morality to the states).


The marriage of these distinct groups produced a conservative political movement of significant influence - once thought to be the albatross of the Republican party, it has proved a rallying cry eliciting tremendous energy and dedication from a staunch core of GOP faithful. By injecting itself (and abortion) into the political arena, the Supreme Court created an enduring legacy of activism on both sides which often dominates the political landscape.


NOTE: It is perhaps ironic that the anniversary of Roe v. Wade immediately succeeds Monday's celebration of black civil rights. One the one hand, the two occasions may be marked as instances of social advancements (aided by judicial decree) for blacks and women, respectively. Conversely, Planned Parenthood founder Margaret Sanger's "Negro Project" explicitly sought to "exterminate" the African-American population through "family planning" - and abortion overwhelmingly targets blacks, ending 1 in every 3 African-American pregnancies.

Recent Comments

(Page 1 of 1)
New Users

Current Users

Add your comments:

Political Machine Photo Galleries

Candidates' Favorite TV Shows
Democrats Debate in Las Vegas
Laura's Trip to Middle East
Political Sex Scandals
The Not-So Traditional 2008 Candidates
Al Gore's Ups and Downs
Spokespersons!
Candidate Spouses

Politics Video

Is McCain to old?

Is McCain to old?

Is John McCain's age a valid issue? CNN's Gary Tuchman reports. (May 16)
McCain accused of Hamas flip

McCain accused of Hamas flip

In an interview two years ago, Sen. John McCain had a different stance on whether Hamas should deal with the U.S. (May 16)
McCain: War will end in 2013

McCain: War will end in 2013

John McCain highlighted his plans as president Thursday and predicted the war in Iraq will be over by 2013. (May 15)
Student elected mayor

Student elected mayor

University of Oklahoma student John Tyler Hammons shares his plans as the newly elected mayor of Muskogee, Oklahoma. (May 15)
Edwards' effect on Obama

Edwards' effect on Obama

Former presidential candidate John Edwards says Sen. Barack Obama can unite the Democratic Party (May 15)
« See More Politics Video