Organ Harvesting Doc On Trial

By Eric Schulzke
Feb 27th 2008 9:56AM

Filed Under:eAbortion

Where is the line between humanitarian and inhuman? A surgeon in California is on trial for administering a deadly drug to a fatally ill handicapped man in order to get him to die more quickly so that they could harvest his organs while they were still useful. His lawyer thinks he did nothing wrong:

The doctor's lawyer, M. Gerald Schwartzbach, said that Roozrokh, 34, who moved to Wisconsin from Iran when he was a toddler and excelled as a collegiate swimmer, did "nothing that adversely affected the quality or length" of Navarro's life.

The man is not innocent. He admits having administered a deadly drug with intent to kill, in clear violation of the Hippocratic oath. Thus, the Kevorkian logic takes its next fully predictable turn of the screw. Handicapped advocates had fought voluntary suicide laws because the line between right to die and duty to die would never hold. As soon as it is OK to take yourself out when you find yourself a pain in the butt, the next step is that someone else will feel entitled to reach the same conclusion.

And they will cloak it in humanitarian logic. These resources -- your organs -- will be better devoted to someone who can better use them. The greatest good for the greatest number. The harsh, inhuman utilitarian logic.

The slippery slope of the abortion logic is in play here. And it's not just found in hospitals with doctors. It's also found in the most prestige universities. Take Peter Singer, the "bioethicist" at Princeton, who believes that infants are not fully human because they lack self-awareness: "I do not think it is always wrong to kill an innocent human being," and "Simply killing an infant is never equivalent to killing a person."

The controversy has the organ donation community flummoxed:
David Fleming, the executive director of Donate Life America, a nonprofit group that promotes donations, said the case had "given some support to the myths and misperceptions we spend an inordinate amount of time telling people won't happen."
Yeah, well, when you spend an inordinate amount of time explaining a myth that people in their gut know is entirely possible unless stiff ethical barriers are in place, and you see society all around you busily disassembling those barriers, it does get a little tough.

Once Nietszsche declared that "God is dead" it was, I suppose, inevitable that the little punks He created would promote themselves to fill the vacancy.

Recent Comments

(Page 1 of 1)
New Users

Current Users

Add your comments:

Latest Elections News Headlines

    No current headlines. Please try again later.

    Political Machine Photo Galleries

    Candidates' Favorite TV Shows
    Democrats Debate in Las Vegas
    Laura's Trip to Middle East
    Political Sex Scandals
    The Not-So Traditional 2008 Candidates
    Al Gore's Ups and Downs
    Spokespersons!
    Candidate Spouses

    Politics Video

    Security And Politics In Iraq

    Security And Politics In Iraq

    As the security situation improves In Iraq, there is still the question of political progress (September 5)
    Supporters: 'Palin Has a Record of Achievement'

    Supporters: 'Palin Has a Record of Achievement'

    Women supporting Gov. Sarah Palin, McCain's vice presidential pick, gathered in St. Paul, Minn., Wednesday to call for an end to 'sexism' in politics. (Sept. 3)
    Obama: No Time for 'small' Politics

    Obama: No Time for 'small' Politics

    At a campaign event in Michigan, presidential nominee Barack Obama said with Hurricane Gustav eyeing the Gulf Coast, there is no time for 'small' politics. (September 1)
    A Trip of the Political Side of the State Fair

    A Trip of the Political Side of the State Fair

    The Minnesota State Fair is not only a marching ground for the school band, but a place for old school retail politics. The AP's John Mone takes a look at how elections are won at this great American gathering. (Aug. 31)
    Mo Rocca 180 - More Than Just Joe Biden!!!

    Mo Rocca 180 - More Than Just Joe Biden!!!

    Mo Rocca 180 - More Than Just Joe Biden!!!
    « See More Politics Video
    Register to Vote with Declare Yourself

    Declare Yourself is a campaign that encourages young Americans to register and vote.

    REGISTER TO VOTE NOW AT:
    www.declareyourself.org