Court Says Border Fence May Proceed

The Supreme Court gave illegal immigration opponents and the Bush administration a key victory today when it rejected a case brought by environmental groups challenging the construction of a section of the new border fence with Mexico. The case challenged the government's right to waive environmental requirements in the construction of a two-mile stretch of the fence near Naco, Arizona. Environmental groups said that the fence jeopardized endangered species that cross the border in the area to mate.

Last year, Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff utilized his power to waive the regulations, under an authorization in the Real ID Act of 2005, to allow the construction of the fence to continue on its rapid pace. About 331 miles of fencing have been constructed in California, Arizona, New Mexico, and Texas, including the disputed two-mile section. Chertoff has used the waiver authority a total of three times, including once to waive seven separate federal regulations for a section of the fence near San Diego, CA. The Department of Homeland Security issued a statement praising the decision.
"As fence construction proceeds, the department will continue to be a good steward of the environment, and consult with appropriate state, local, and tribal officials."


Critics of the department and the border fence said that the decision and the fence would ultimately have no impact on the illegal immigration problem. "I am extremely disappointed in the court's decision," said Rep. Bennie Thompson (D-MS), Chairman of the House Homeland Security Committee. "Without a comprehensive plan, this fence is just another quick fix."

But the American people do not support a comprehensive approach to immigration reform, as the failure of the 2006 Senate immigration compromise demonstrated. Americans support enforcement of the border first, and may be willing to revisit the nation's immigration system after some control over the flow of illegal immigrants has been established. Today's decision by the Court will be embraced by a majority of the population not only as upholding the law as passed by Congress, but as a common sense approach to a growing problem.

Recent Comments

(Page 1 of 1)
New Users

Current Users

Add your comments:

Political Machine Photo Galleries

Candidates' Favorite TV Shows
Democrats Debate in Las Vegas
Laura's Trip to Middle East
Political Sex Scandals
The Not-So Traditional 2008 Candidates
Al Gore's Ups and Downs
Spokespersons!
Candidate Spouses

Politics Video

Bush on Georgian conflict

Bush on Georgian conflict

President Bush makes a statement on Georgia during his visit to CIA Headquarters in Langley, Virginia. (August 14)
Pastor won't play 'gotcha'

Pastor won't play 'gotcha'

Pastor Rick Warren won't play 'gotcha' with the presidential candidates this weekend at his forum. (August 14)
McCain criticizes Putin

McCain criticizes Putin

Sen. John McCain discusses the Russia-Georgia conflict at the Aspen Institute. (August 14)
Gearing up for the conventions

Gearing up for the conventions

CNN Political Editor Mark Preston explains why Clinton is still a winner, and why some RNC members are staying home. (August 14)
Strategy Session

Strategy Session

The Situation Room Strategy Session. CNN's Wolf Blitzer discusses the Edwards affair. (August 15)
« See More Politics Video
Register to Vote with Declare Yourself

Declare Yourself is a campaign that encourages young Americans to register and vote.

REGISTER TO VOTE NOW AT:
www.declareyourself.org